Document Type




Format of Original

15 p.

Publication Date



Taylor & Francis (Routledge)

Source Publication

Review of Political Economy

Source ISSN



This paper investigates a number of aspects of Piero Sraffa's early philosophical thinking by placing him within the historical materialist tradition of reasoning about the relation of ideas to the historical process. It first distinguishes Alfred Marshall's views about the historical development of ideas by addressing Marshall's responses to the criticisms of William Cunningham of the English Historical School. Marshall's concept of economics as a universal engine of discovery was rejected by Sraffa in his early writings. Sraffa's critique of Marshall is then argued to lead to two early philosophical commitments on Sraffa's part: that deductivist modes of explanation are inappropriate in economics and that economics aims to explain the underlying structures of causal interaction that had been the concern of the classical political economists. The paper closes with brief remarks on how Sraffa's later philosophical thinking might be approached.


Accepted version. Review of Political Economy, Vol. 10, No. 4 (1998): 477-491. DOI. © 1998 Taylor & Francis. Used with permission.

davis_3965acc.docx (51 kB)
ADA Accessible Version

Included in

Economics Commons