"Commentary on Halper" by Owen Goldin
 

Commentary on Halper

Document Type

Article

Language

eng

Publication Date

2018

Publisher

Brill Academic Publishers

Source Publication

Proceedings of the Boston Area Colloquium in Ancient Philosophy

Source ISSN

1059-986x

Abstract

Edward Halper's "The Metaphysics of the Syllogism" argues that the ontological ground of valid inference is found in the necessity of the predications that constitute the prem­ises of the sort of syllogism central to Aristotle's theory: demonstration. I further sup­port his conclusion on the basis of a consideration of the title and structure of Aristotle's Analytics, as well as some recent analysis of Aristotle's modal logic. Halper however sug­gests mat the logical form of inference is a result of how the mind sorts out the elements involved in a complex unity. I suggest that it is not primarily the mind that does this work, but language. What the mind does is primarily to be understood as a reflection of what language does, not vice versa.

Comments

Proceedings of the Boston Area Colloquium in Ancient Philosophy, Vol. 33, No. 1 (2018): 61-67. DOI.

Share

COinS