Review of La Condanna del Modernismo: Documenti, Interpretazioni, Conseguenze, edited by Claus Arnold and Giovanni Vian
Format of Original
Catholic University of America Press
Catholic Historical Review
Original Item ID
The 2002 opening of the Vatican archives to scholars through 1922 has enabled a series of highly illuminating publications on the modernist period, the most recent being the present volume. Claus Arnold introduces this superb collection with an astute observation:To understand the modernist crisis on its own terms, one must see it in the context of the struggle between Christianity and “modernity” from the early Renaissance to the present; ecclesiastical opponents saw modernism as but an acute phase of this age-old confrontation. Decisions made during this acute phase had, Arnold observes, precedents in Pope Leo XIII’s interventions regarding biblical criticism, which Pope Pius X escalated to a worldwide antimodernist campaign with chilling consequences lasting to the present day.
Schultenover, David G., "Review of La Condanna del Modernismo: Documenti, Interpretazioni, Conseguenze, edited by Claus Arnold and Giovanni Vian" (2012). Theology Faculty Research and Publications. 205.
Published version. Catholic Historical Review, Vol. 98, No. 1, (January 2012): 145-147. DOI. © 2012 Catholic University of America Press. Used with permission.